In a heartfelt revelation that has reignited fervor among The Witcher fans, Freya Allan, the talented actress who brings Ciri to life on Netflix’s hit series, has openly shared her deep sense of loss over no longer working with Henry Cavill. The British star, now 23, didn’t hold back during a recent interview, admitting that she and many of her castmates feel a void since Cavill stepped away from his iconic role as Geralt of Rivia after Season 3. Allan’s candid remarks, tinged with both nostalgia and a flicker of hope, have struck a chord with the show’s passionate fanbase, many of whom echo her sentiment with a resounding, “We truly miss the real Geralt.” Her wistful plea for Netflix to bring Cavill back has only amplified the ongoing debate about the future of the fantasy epic.

Cavill’s departure from The Witcher, announced in late 2022, sent shockwaves through the fandom. After three seasons of embodying the stoic, white-haired monster hunter with a blend of intensity and vulnerability, the 41-year-old actor bowed out, citing a desire to pursue other projects—rumored to include his return as Superman in the DC Universe. Replacing him is Liam Hemsworth, a casting choice that has divided viewers even before his debut in Season 4, currently in production. While Hemsworth brings his own charisma, Cavill’s Geralt had become synonymous with the character, earning praise for his fidelity to Andrzej Sapkowski’s books and the beloved video game adaptations by CD Projekt Red. For Allan, losing Cavill wasn’t just a professional shift—it was personal.

Speaking to a entertainment outlet this week, Allan reflected on their time together with palpable emotion. “Henry was the heart of the show in so many ways,” she said. “He brought this incredible energy—dedicated, passionate, and just so easy to work with. We truly miss the real Geralt.” The actress, who joined The Witcher at 17 and grew up alongside Cavill’s mentorship, described their on-set dynamic as familial. “He was like a big brother to me,” she added. “He’d always check in, give advice, and make sure I was okay, especially during those grueling fight scenes.” Her words paint a picture of a bond that transcended their roles, one that fans argue was palpable in their chemistry as Geralt and Ciri—the surrogate father and daughter at the story’s core.

Allan’s longing isn’t just about nostalgia; it’s rooted in the belief that Cavill’s Geralt was irreplaceable. “He was Geralt,” she insisted. “The way he moved, the way he spoke those lines—it felt authentic, like he’d stepped right out of the books. I keep wishing Netflix would find a way to bring him back.” Her comments tap into a broader sentiment among the cast and crew, some of whom have privately expressed unease about the transition. While Allan was careful not to criticize Hemsworth directly—she called him “lovely” and “committed”—her preference for Cavill is clear, fueling speculation about whether Netflix might reconsider its plans.

The fan response has been swift and vocal. On X, hashtags like #BringBackHenry and #RealGeralt have surged, with thousands of posts echoing Allan’s sentiments. “Freya gets it—Henry IS Geralt. Netflix messed up,” one fan tweeted, while another wrote, “Seeing Ciri herself say this breaks my heart. We need him back.” The outcry isn’t new; since Cavill’s exit, petitions have circulated, and some fans have even threatened to boycott future seasons. The discontent stems not just from loyalty to Cavill but from a perceived disconnect between Netflix’s vision and the franchise’s roots—a tension exacerbated by Season 2’s divisive creative choices, which Cavill himself reportedly clashed with producers over.

For Allan, the shift has also meant adjusting to a new dynamic as The Witcher moves into its penultimate season. With Season 4 set to explore Ciri’s growing powers and her entanglement with the Deathless Mother, Allan’s role is expanding, placing her at the narrative forefront. Yet, she admitted the absence of Cavill’s grounding presence has made the process bittersweet. “It’s different now,” she said. “We’re all trying to adapt, but there’s this feeling that something’s missing.” Her hope for his return, though slim, reflects a dream shared by many: a surprise cameo, perhaps, or a twist that sees Cavill’s Geralt reenter the fray in the multiverse-heavy finale planned for Season 5.

Netflix has remained tight-lipped, with no indication of reversing course. Hemsworth’s casting is locked in, and promotional materials for Season 4 are expected soon, signaling the streamer’s commitment to moving forward. Still, Allan’s words have added fuel to an already blazing fire, raising questions about whether fan pressure—and the cast’s own sentiments—could sway the studio. Cavill, for his part, has stayed gracious, recently praising Hemsworth while expressing gratitude for his time as Geralt. “It was an honor to wield the silver sword,” he said in a statement last month, leaving the door ever-so-slightly ajar.

As The Witcher barrels toward its endgame, Allan’s candid confession underscores the challenge Netflix faces in retaining the soul of the series. For her and countless fans, Cavill’s Geralt was more than a performance—he was the beating heart of a world they cherished. Whether her wish comes true or fades into wistful memory, one thing is certain: the cry of “We truly miss the real Geralt” won’t be silenced anytime soon. The White Wolf’s legacy, it seems, is far from finished howling.